News >> Browse Articles >> Hardware
LCD Makers Plead Guilty to Price Fixing
Shane McGlaun / DailyTech
November 13, 2008
‘Fines to involved firms total $585 million.’ -
The economy is tough currently around the world and here in America. While most technology firms simply do the best they can in the current economic climate, some take things too far and turn to illegal means to protect profits.
This was the case for three of the top LCD panel makers in the world. Sharp, LG, and Chunghwa Picture Tubes have all pled guilty to price fixing in the LCD market. The three firms have agreed to pay fines totaling $585 million to the U.S. Justice Department.
The largest fine levied against one of the three firms was against LG. LG alone is responsible for $400 million of the fine with the remaining $85 million coming from Sharp and Chunghwa. The exact amount that the latter two firms will pay is unknown.
The New York Times reports that the $400 million fine against LG is the second largest fine ever levied by the Justice Department’s antitrust division. The largest was a $500 million fine paid by F. Hoffman-La Roche in 1999 for price fixing in nutritional supplements.
These fines may be the end of the price fixing saga for the three firms here in the U.S., but things in Europe and Asia are just getting started. The investigation was conducted jointly between authorities in the U.S., Europe, and Asia.
When all is said and done the total cost for each of the LCD makers will be much higher than the U.S. fines alone. In addition to fines from the Justice Department, the New York Times reports that several class action suits have been filed on behalf of consumers and distributors who purchased screens made by the companies.
Three American firms who purchased LCD panels from the companies in the scandal specifically named by the Justice Department are Dell, Apple, and Motorola. If the price fixing scheme hadn’t been executed by the firms, the panels would be even cheaper than they are now according to authorities.
These LCD makers aren’t the only tech companies who have been in trouble for price fixing. NVIDIA agreed to a settlement without admitting guilt over alleged price fixing in the GPU industry.
© 2008, DailyTech

money
11 months ago
74 comments
Man o man, 400 million is alot to pay back, but it is nothing to them, i am sure,
asheen
about 1 year ago
2 comments
For those that have not caught on yet... These companies were price fixing the "parts" which led to higher prices per unit. Most other companies bought parts form these three manufacturers. The dumb statement about the oil companies... We are not being screwed by the oil companies. Don't rely on the news to give you the best info. Research how companies that peddle commodities work. The "cost" is not what they actually pay. It is a number based on the activity in the stock market.. The next time you have a hard time with the Gas and Fuel prices look to the government which, has the ability to but, does nothing to limit trading on oil and gas.
gadgetdan
about 1 year ago
2 comments
Android said: [If these TVs were so overpriced then WHY THE HELL DID YOU BUY IT!!! It doesnt take a rocket scientist to get on Google and do a price comparison.]
Fixing prices of component parts through a conspiracy with your competitors affects EVERY price you see in your google search. Do your search, then realize that every single hit should have been 5-10% cheaper.
They didn't get in trouble because YOU may have paid too much, they got in trouble for an anti-trust conspiracy to make EVERYBODY pay too much.
IOW, no, you won't see a dime of profit or rebate from this decision...but neither will they. If fact, I'm betting some high-ranking folks in these corporations may be updating their resumes right now.
stevarino
about 1 year ago
4 comments
Thanks for your response. Maybe free enterprise isn't such a good idea. Or perhaps a growing government watchdog is just what we'll have to pay for to "protect" us as we convert to socialism from a democracy--right after we convince the soviets to do the opposite.
Seamus
about 1 year ago
66 comments
sukebe: Look where that mentality got us. ;)
huangpo
about 1 year ago
2 comments
Price fixing means that 2 or more companies agree to charge the same amount instead of competing against each other in price. These 3 LCD manufacturers provide the majority of LCD screens.
sukebe
about 1 year ago
2 comments
I think the companies should be able to steal as much money from us as possible for their crappy products. Why should the oil companies be the only ones? I mean, why should we every have a justice department anyway? the "market" should be trusted to run everything for us: Insurance, loans, fire department, police... everything. They're very smart and always looking out for us... more than our government.
alexandersuarez
about 1 year ago
14 comments
Once they become broke due to these fines, the government will have to give back the money to bailed them out and keep people employee. This is the ironi of the economic situation.
stevarino
about 1 year ago
4 comments
I just don't get it. We as consumers decide what we pay. It's a supply/demand sort of thing. Companies I would think have the right to charge whatever they think they can get, right? It's called 'capitalism', what we were built on. And another large screen maker can come along and undercharge them, right? Then folks will buy the least expensive of the two, right?
volend
about 1 year ago
2 comments
Ok fix your story. First you say its $585M, then you say that LG has to pay $400M and the other companies have to pay the rest which is: $85M. Now, which is it? Is it $485M or $585M ??? Because if it is $585M then it is the BIGGEST fine not the second biggest. Roach paid: $500M.
klaus97685
about 1 year ago
2 comments
This is b ll@hit why does the Justice Department make out if there was a crime against humanity?
android700
about 1 year ago
2 comments
A classic example of the liberal plague that has swept America. If these TVs were so overpriced then WHY THE HELL DID YOU BUY IT!!! It doesnt take a rocket scientist to get on Google and do a price comparison. The US govt. has become one of the most spineless institutions around. If old people are dumb enough to pay 2 grand for a 26" lcd, then they deserve what they get. Last i checked they still make the big box TVs at bone-low prices, and these will be perfect for our geriatric imbociles.
Estreen
about 1 year ago
4 comments
And not everyone is "product savvy" either. A lot of consumers (like people in my parents' age group) wouldn't know if they're being over-charged or not, and that's not their fault. Bottom line is that those companies did wrong, and I'm sure if someone *knew* that it was over-priced, then they would not purchase it to begin with.
motosys
about 1 year ago
2 comments
to the person whom asked will the prices by these manufacturers drop on there tv's the answer is all manufactures displays will drop as you could buy a veiwsonic monitor and it would have an LG screen in it these are the manufacturers of the screens that other manufacturers put into their displays otherwise the price fixing would not work only 3 makers is not enough to affect the market. These 3 companies produce all of the screens used by all manufacturers so you should see a price drop across the board from all manufacturers
Kaelin
about 1 year ago
2 comments
No one forced you to spend that on an lcd screen.
We are not a communist country over here lol.
Always looking for a handout.